When it comes to getting married, selecting the right engagement ring is one of the most significant decisions you'll make. One of the first questions that often comes to mind is, “How much should I spend?” While there is no ‘right amount’, the answer for you will depending on several factors. The best place to start in answering this question is to understand the elements that influence the cost of an engagement ring to help guide your decision.
1. Understanding the Pricing of Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamonds
Diamonds, whether natural or lab-grown, are the focal point of most engagement rings. The price of a diamond is determined by several factors: carat weight, cut, clarity, and colour, commonly known as the “Four Cs.” Due to the variation in quality, the price range is substantial. Here is a guideline on what you can expect to pay:
Natural Diamonds
A 0.5ct round natural diamond with an I colour and VS1 clarity would cost in the region of $1 550.00 (R27 435.00). A whiter stone such as a G VS for the same size (0.5ct round) would cost $1890.00 (R33 450.00). The bigger the stone and the higher cut and clarity the more expensive the stone becomes. Prices are also based on availability. With this broad spectrum it can be challenging to decide on what’s right, especially if you are working with a specific budget. Do you get a larger stone and settle on the colour and clarity? Or do you get a smaller stone that’s better quality? Or now with technological innovation – do you choose to buy a lab-grown diamond? The options can seem overwhelming, which is why it’s so important to do your research, be guided by a reputable jeweller and understand the desires of your partner to help guide your decision.
Lab-Grown Diamonds
Lab-grown diamonds remain a hot topic in the jewellery world, often stirring debate due to their relatively new presence in the market. These diamonds possess the same brilliance, clarity, and specifications as their natural counterparts but come at a fraction of the cost. For instance, a 1ct round diamond with an E colour grade and VS clarity would cost around $570 (R10 000.00). If diamond size is important to your partner and you're working within a budget, lab-grown diamonds can be an excellent option—a 2ct round E VS is priced in the region of $1,020 (R18 000.00).
Choosing between a natural and a lab-grown diamond is about so much more than just the price. Natural diamonds have their own special magic—formed deep within the Earth over billions of years, each one is unique and carries a story. They have a certain rarity, a potential for resale value, and often a sentimental quality that can’t be replicated.
Lab-grown diamonds, on the other hand, are just as beautiful and identical in every way to natural ones. They're also a great choice for those who value sustainability, especially when created using renewable energy. And, of course, they can offer a little more sparkle for your budget.
Our suggestion? Have an open conversation with your partner about what matters most to them. If you’re planning a surprise, you might ask a close friend to find out subtly.
2. Exploring Other Gemstone Options
While diamonds are a traditional favourite for engagement rings, there are many other beautiful gemstones worth considering. Precious gemstones like sapphires, rubies, tanzanites, and emeralds carry a deep sense of energy and symbolism. These stones hold significant value and are often priced similarly to natural diamonds, though the cost can vary greatly based on their quality and size. If your partner loves a pop of colour and you want to explore a more cost-effective main stone, semi-precious gems like garnets, amethysts, and aquamarines are wonderful options. These stones not only offer captivating beauty at a more accessible price but also carry their own unique energy and meanings.
Exploring other gemstones opens the possibility of incorporating personal symbolism and meaning—like using your and your partner’s birthstones in the design. This can be a wonderful way to make the ring truly sentimental and unique, reflecting your shared story and the personality of your love.
3. The Gemstone You Didn’t Consider | Jewellery Remodelling
A service we specialise in, and something many people don’t consider, is the option to use existing gemstones from jewellery that is no longer worn, or something deeply sentimental to carry through a second generation. Like a bride using fabric from her mother’s wedding dress or even (with a classic style) wearing her dress decades later on her own wedding day, you can remodel your mom’s or your future bride’s mom or even a grandmother’s wedding ring or other pieces of jewellery. Not only does this create something deeply meaningful, but it can significantly reduce your cost while also being a sustainable environmental practice of reusing gemstones.
4. What Determines the Price of an Engagement Ring?
Several elements contribute to the overall cost of an engagement ring beyond the diamond or gemstone itself:
Metal Choice:
Gold (375): Also known as 9ct gold, this alloy contains 37.5% pure gold and 62.5% other metals such as copper, silver, or zinc. Its lower gold content makes it a more affordable option while providing excellent durability.
Gold (750): Also referred to as 18ct gold, this alloy is composed of 75% pure gold and 25% other metals like copper, silver, or palladium. The higher gold content gives it a richer hue and greater intrinsic value. 18ct gold maintains strong durability, making it a premium choice for those seeking both elegance and longevity in their jewellery.
Platinum: Renowned for its exceptional durability and hypoallergenic properties, platinum is an excellent choice for jewellery. Its high melting point, however, can make it more challenging for intricate designs, potentially affecting the final finish. It is particularly well-suited for men's wedding bands or simpler designs, such as solitaires.
For an engagement ring, we recommend 18ct gold for its exceptional durability making it ideal for daily wear. However, if budget constraints are a consideration, 9ct gold remains a good choice, combining affordability with durability while still ensuring a stunning and enduring piece.
The Setting:
The intricacy of the setting can add to the cost. A solitaire setting is typically less expensive than a halo or pavé setting, which requires more diamonds and craftsmanship. Additionally, the weight of metal in the ring also affects the price; the heavier the weight, the higher the cost.
5. What’s the Right Budget for You and Your Partner?
Deciding on your engagement ring isn’t just about numbers—it’s about knowing your partner and what they value. Is your future wife someone who loves luxury, fashion, and a bit of bling? If so, she might appreciate a more substantial investment in the ring with a larger main stone. On the other hand, if she’s the type who enjoys the outdoors and prefers simplicity, a smaller budget and simple design might be the perfect choice for something special she can wear every day.
There’s no right or wrong here; it’s about understanding the kind of person your partner is, what they value, and what expectations they might have. It’s important that you don’t feel pressured to spend more than you’re comfortable with—at the end of the day, your engagement ring is a symbol of committing to your partner and representing your love. This should be at the forefront when looking at costs, designs, and other aspects. However, it’s also important to note that you should not rush into an engagement ring without adequate time for preparation and saving—cutting corners could lead to future regrets or compromising on the ring design. Be realistic and take your time.
6. The Importance of Expertise, Experience, and Craftsmanship
Many jewellers experience clients coming to them after purchasing rings that didn’t quite meet their expectations. Cases include not using enough claws to set a very large diamond, leading to distress when the stone fell out, or a wedding band made too thin, resulting in it snapping under pressure. When you choose a jeweller, you are entrusting them to guide you, utilise their experience and expertise, and highlight what is not advisable. This is ultimately the premium you choose to pay, and why the price of an engagement ring will vary significantly depending on the jeweller you choose. You are investing in years of experience, craftsmanship, and the assurance that your ring is designed to last. Remember, an engagement ring is a piece of jewellery intended to be worn for a lifetime; it deserves the best.
To put it into perspective, consider the experience of a road trip. Imagine embarking on a three-day journey. Would you rather travel in a car that’s comfortable, reliable, and equipped with state-of-the-art features, or in a vehicle that might get you to your destination but not without a few bumps along the way? Both cars can get you from point A to B, but the experience is vastly different. The comfort, security, and satisfaction you feel in a premium car can transform the journey, making it an enjoyable and stress-free experience.
7. Insurance Premiums and Jewellery Aftercare
Once you’ve received your dream ring, it’s essential to consider insurance and aftercare. Even for high-value pieces, insurance premiums are often nominal. However, ensuring your ring is adequately insured is an important step to protect your investment. It’s worth discussing this aspect with your jeweller during the design process. They can provide insights into the best insurance options and offer guidance on aftercare, ensuring that your ring remains as stunning as the day you proposed. Remember, just like a car, your ring requires regular maintenance to keep it in top condition. An annual inspection by a professional jeweller is essential to check for any signs of wear and tear, such as loose stones or weakened settings. Depending on how often it’s worn, white gold rings may need rhodium plating every 1-2 years to restore their lustre, and all types of metal may benefit from occasional refurbishing to smooth out scratches and enhance their shine. Additionally, a professional cleaning every 6 months will help remove dirt and oils that can dull the sparkle, ensuring your ring looks as radiant as the day you first wore it.
So Now, How Much Should You Spend on an Engagement Ring?
When it comes to budgeting for an engagement ring, as you can see there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Simple designs can start around R15,000 ($845), but these may not offer the best in terms of design potential or stone size. At Jenna Clifford, we advise our clients to budget at least R30,000 ($1 690) as a starting point for a custom engagement ring, offering a piece that is not only beautiful but also crafted to last a lifetime. However, our custom design services are flexible, allowing us to work within your preferred budget to select or create the perfect engagement ring for you.
Remember, the value of an engagement ring goes beyond its price tag. It’s a reflection of your commitment, and it should be something you’re proud to give and that your partner will cherish forever.
Conclusion
Setting a budget for your engagement ring requires a thoughtful balance of trusting your intuition, understanding the technical aspects of the design and gemstone sourcing, and considering the unique personality and values of your future wife. Ultimately, it's about finding a ring that reflects what she truly values and cherishes.
Even now that you’ve delved into the details and gained insights into your options, the best next step is to consult with a jewellery specialist. They can provide expert guidance tailored to your budget and preferences and answer any questions you might have. At Jenna Clifford, we are committed to helping you find a ring that is both stunning and deeply meaningful, ensuring it’s a perfect symbol of your relationship and the journey you’re embarking on together.
Comments